Male/Female setting looks opposite
closed
S_ASAGIRI@VRC
Version:
SDK 2019.04.01.10.09
Description of the bug:
Male/Female setting (Default Animation Set in the VRC Avatar Descriptor) seems to be opposite. When I choose "Male", the avatar becomes pigeon-toed, while when I choose "Female" the avatar becomes duck-footed. This behavior looks opposite.
Log In
Fax
closed
These animation are still available in SDK3 in 'proxy' form, if you'd like to continue using them.
Interestingly, the male and female pose came from a male and female animation set respectively. The swap may have been intentional for better retargeting of hip bones! 😲
ni1chigo2115
when?
owlboy
S_ASAGIRI@VRC is this still happening?
S_ASAGIRI@VRC
Additional information
・Only the "idle standing animation" seems to be opposite.
・When the avatar is sitting, its idle animation looks correct.
・Avatar's fingers slowly move when I choose "male", but it doesn't work when I choose "female".
S_ASAGIRI@VRC
In addition, the legs bend too inwardly (see image below) when I choose "Male" in some cases.
LunarLapNeko
S_ASAGIRI@VRC: legs bending inwards is because the knee bone roll is not 0 (select the bones in blender and hit ctrl+R)
could be the same reason for the idle standing pose
also make sure they knees are a bit forwards in side view but straight in front view
S_ASAGIRI@VRC
LunarLapNeko: Thank you for the information about the knee bone angle.
I confirmed them, but the mismatch of the standing pose occurs even though the roll angle is 0 and the knees are a bit forwards.
H
Hugo Zink
LunarLapNeko: the knees bending inwards is actually generally just a result of the knees not being bent enough in Blender. The resting pose needs a little bit of bend in it.
Niyah
S_ASAGIRI@VRC: Actually, the "male" one just fuck up the crouch idle, been a thing since over 2 years.
It's not about the roll or anything since the model work perfectly in FBT & with the female set.
Yet another bug that VRChat could fix by just... removing it tbh, we don't need two set of default animations.
Mr. Jekk
Niyah: I like your solution of just reducing down to a single humanoid default animation set.